KOPTA TERITORIJA · Garden advice that gets to the point
Smaragd or Brabant? Both look good. You’ll be doing the trimming.
At the nursery, it all looks simple: green thujas, a tidy row - you want the same. But you buy the plants today. You live with their growth for years.
Choose Smaragd if you like slim, conical shapes and want less frequent shaping. Choose Brabant if you want a faster-growing green boundary and are ready to trim it regularly. Both are varieties of Thuja occidentalis. Choose around the way you want to use your garden and the upkeep you’re willing to take on.
Smaragd and Brabant: similar at first glance. Different to live with.
Dense, conical growth and a slower pace. Keeps its green colour well through winter. A good fit if you like a row of distinct, slender thujas. It can form a hedge too.
Faster growth and a looser crown. A good choice for a clipped green wall. But that level top and those dense sides come from regular trimming.
“Fast-growing” sounds great. Until the first trim. Then you realise all that new growth needs managing. If you want to keep Brabant at a set height and width, plan for the upkeep from the start.
Smaragd moves at a different pace. Its natural outline needs less shaping. But “slower-growing” doesn’t mean “forever the size it was when you bought it”.
There’s room for the thuja beside the fence. Will there still be room for you in a few years?
One thing to try before buying
First, the string. Then, the thujas.
Mark out your planting line. Then lay a length of string or a garden hose where the garden-facing edge of the mature hedge will be. Use the width you intend to maintain by trimming.
Now walk alongside it. Open the gate. Step over to the flower bed. Still comfortable? Is there room to trim the side of the hedge?
You’ve just tried your future hedge for size - before buying a single plant. If the space already feels tight, rethink the planting position or planned width. A small thuja won’t show you how much room a mature row will take up.
A green wall or a row of neat cones?
- Like the look of individual, tidy thujas? Take a look at Smaragd: its conical shape is part of the appeal.
- Want a straight, clipped boundary? Consider Brabant - and decide who will keep it in shape.
- Prefer fewer dates with the hedge trimmer? Smaragd’s slower growth may suit you better.
- Need privacy straight away? Look at the height, width and density of the actual plants. A variety name won’t block the view on its own.
One more thing: neither variety gets you out of watering after planting. If water sits on the ground, the soil dries out quickly or the site is exposed to wind, we need to assess those conditions first. A nice name on the label won’t fix them.
The price of one thuja isn’t the price of a hedge, either. Plant numbers, size, ground preparation and thuja planting all matter. We work out the total cost once the site details and scope are clear.
For more on upkeep, read “How much does thuja hedge trimming cost?” .
Smaragd or Brabant: what else should you know?
Will Brabant give me privacy sooner?
In comparable conditions, it usually grows faster. But the time needed depends on plant size, spacing and care. Without those details, nobody can promise a complete green wall by a particular year.
Is Smaragd a “plant and forget” option?
No. It may not need shaping if you’re happy with its natural form and have room for it to grow. But watering, checking plant health and managing growth in a tight space are still part of the job.
Can Smaragd make a dense hedge?
Yes, but its conical shape affects the look of the row: gaps can remain between the pointed tops. If you want a level green wall, discuss that before choosing the plants.
Plant them closer and get a hedge sooner?
Closer spacing can help gaps fill sooner, but “the closer, the better” isn’t a general rule. Spacing should reflect the variety, plant size and the shape of the future hedge.